12.11.2012

Copycat Bauder's Peppermint Bar, in a Pie!



If you’ve ever enjoyed ice cream from the Bauder Pharmacy stand at the Iowa State Fair, chances are pretty good that you’re going to melt over my next two words:

Peppermint.

Bar.

And if you have no idea what I’m talking about…

You. Are. Missing. Out.

Big time.

(By the way, that’s “YAMO” for you acronym-texting, smart phone junkies. I made it up. Unless someone else already did…I don’t know. I don’t text!)

Like most fairgoers, I have my list of must-have foods to be eaten once-a-year at the fair. But unlike many fairgoers, other than a Campbell’s corndog, the rest of my list cannot be eaten on a stick. A BBQ pork sandwich dinner at the pork tent, deep-fried cheese curds, a cup of Barksdale’s cookies, the all-you-can-eat pancake breakfast at Cattleman’s Beef Quarters (where they serve pork sausage), honey lemonade in the Ag building, and at the top of my list…..a peppermint bar from Bauder’s.

Pink peppermint-stick ice cream is piled high between two layers of crushed Oreo cookies and a layer of hot fudge, neatly wrapped in red-and-white-checkered tissue paper, and served with a spoon. (Check out a few photos at My Homemade Iowa Life.) Except for the bite or two that my sister always manages to mooch off of me, I’m not too keen on sharing this once-a-year treat. Which is kind of funny, because every year we say that we should make them at home so we can enjoy them more often than once a year.

Then we realize that we need peppermint stick ice cream, and in August, when it’s 326° outside and the humidity in Iowa makes it feel like 800°, you can’t find a winter-themed ice cream flavor in any grocery store north of the equator. I’ve checked.

So, we soon forget all about our novel idea to extend a favorite summer treat. But this year, when the first carton hit the freezer shelves at my local grocery store, I again thought of those Bauder’s peppermint bars. Since I’ve been making pie every week, I wondered about turning that peppermint bar into a pie. So I did!

For this first go-round, I went all out. Knowing that peppermint stick ice cream is a limited-time flavor, I decided making my own would allow for somewhat impromptu indulgence of this treat any time of year…dangerous I’ll admit, but for now I’ll take my chances. And for all the scratch cooking and baking I do, I realized that I had never made my own hot fudge sauce. So this seemed like the perfect opportunity to start.

I had no idea how many ways there are to make hot fudge sauce, and my first attempt (that already sounds like it ends badly) wasn’t exactly what I was looking for in hot fudge. The first sauce I made with corn syrup and cocoa was a little hard and chewy when served on ice cream, likely because I overcooked it. (I had to test it, what do you expect?)

I needed a sauce to withstand the freezer without becoming too hard. I came across a recipe using sweetened condensed milk and chocolate chips. I wanted a more-chocolaty flavor than I got with the cocoa, so I thought I’d try it. This hot fudge was just what I wanted. So good! The real test was in the fact that I kept going back to the fridge with a spoon. (And it wasn’t for the good-for-you sautéed kale and mushroom dish on the middle shelf. Which I happen to like a lot.)

Start to finish, it took a little while to make this pie, mostly in waiting time. Waiting for the ice cream mixture to chill. Waiting for the hot fudge sauce to cool and chill. Waiting for my daughter to crush the candy canes (after waiting for her to unwrap them first – I didn’t want to eat plastic). Waiting for the ice cream to firm up in the Oreo cookie crust-lined pie plate in the freezer.

Waiting for this pie to be finished is also why you have waited to read about it. But trust me. It’s worth it!


If you don’t want to wait as long as I did, you can go the convenience route and use a premade Oreo cookie crust, store-bought peppermint-stick ice cream, and a jar of commercial hot fudge sauce (my recommendation would be Mrs. Richardson’s). Either way, you won’t have to wait until August for the Iowa State Fair to roll around again. You can enjoy this copycat version of Bauder’s famous peppermint bar – in a pie – whenever you want.

You’ll even have enough to share with your sister.

Yours in pie,

Mindy

This recipe looks lengthy, but you can easily prepare each part ahead of time and assemble it all at once when you’re ready. If you decide to forego homemade and settle on convenience, you will need: a prepared Oreo cookie crust, 1 quart peppermint-stick ice cream, 8 oz. hot fudge sauce, 18 Oreo cookies (for the topping), 2 candy canes, and a partridge in a pear tree. (Just kidding on the last one. That wouldn’t be very tasty.)

Peppermint Bar Ice Cream Pie

For the crust:

18 Oreo cookies

3 T. melted butter


Pulse cookies in a food processor or place inside a re-sealable bag and crush with a rolling pin. Gradually add melted butter and combine well. Press mixture into pie plate (I used a 9-inch deep-dish pie plate) and refrigerate until ready to use.


For the ice cream:

from Itsy Bitsy Foodies, with slight changes

(This made a full 1 ½ quarts of ice cream in my machine. You'll need about 1 quart for the pie.)


3 eggs, well beaten

2 c. whole milk

1 c. sugar

2 c. heavy cream

1½ tsp. vanilla extract

1 tsp. peppermint extract

3-5 drops red food coloring

1 c. crushed candy canes

In a large saucepan, beat the eggs, milk and sugar until well blended. Cook over low heat for about 20 minutes, stirring constantly, until thickened. It should smoothly coat the back of a wooden spoon. Cool completely. Add the heavy cream, vanilla, peppermint extract and food coloring. Stir until blended and refrigerate until completely chilled, for several hours or overnight.

Use a meat tenderizer or rolling pin to crush the candy canes (some will be finely crushed, others in small pieces). Following the instructions for your ice cream maker, pour the chilled mixture into your machine and process, adding crushed candy canes according to machine instructions (usually five minutes before ice cream is finished). Transfer the ice cream to a sealed container and let it ripen for several hours. Or…

At this point in making the pie, you can carefully spoon ice cream into chilled prepared cookie crust, then place in the freezer to firm up. You will need approximately one quart (4 cups) of the ice cream. Don’t overfill the pie plate! Be sure to save some room at the top of the pie plate for adding the hot fudge layer and the cookie/candy cane topping.


For the hot fudge sauce:

(This makes 2 cups, but you'll only need 1 cup for the pie.)

1 c. (6 oz.) semi-sweet chocolate chips

1 (14 oz.) can Eagle Brand® Sweetened Condensed Milk

2 T. butter

2 T. water

1 tsp. vanilla extract


Melt chocolate chips with sweetened condensed milk, butter and water in medium-sized heavy saucepan over medium heat. Beat smooth with wire whisk if necessary. Stir in vanilla. Cool and store in refrigerator.

For the cookie topping:

18 Oreo cookies

2 large candy canes


Place cookies in a re-sealable bag and gently crush with a rolling pin, leaving slightly large chunks, so the cookies look more like crumbles rather than finely crushed. Set aside. Use a meat tenderizer or rolling pin to crush the candy canes, leaving mostly large chunks. Set aside.


Once the ice cream has set firm in the prepared cookie crust, slightly warm the fudge sauce in the microwave just enough to make it pourable. You don’t want it warm enough to melt the ice cream. You’ll need about 1 cup of the sauce. Carefully pour it onto the ice cream and spread evenly with an offset spatula. Carefully sprinkle on the crumbled Oreo cookies and press gently into the fudge sauce. Sprinkle on the candy cane chunks. Return pie to freezer to firm up until ready to eat.

When serving, remove pie from freezer and let it set at room temperature for 5 minutes or so, to make slicing easier.

Enjoy!

12.03.2012

Patience and a Peanut Butter Pie


I think I may disappoint you.

(If you can’t handle it, then you should stop reading now. But if you do, you’ll miss a hint about next Sunday’s pie. So, you should probably just keep reading.)

On Saturday, I spent the morning at a gift market fundraiser for my daughter’s preschool. I had baked four pies – two apple-blackberry and two chocolate chip pecan – for the bake sale, which had a wide assortment of delicious-looking home-baked treats. My kids each brought their own money so they could buy something. My daughter quickly decided on a plate of mint crème brownies, and my son, after what seemed like hours of deliberation, finally settled on one whoopee pie and a plate of oatmeal chocolate chip cookies.

While my kids were searching out the perfect treat to take home, I decided on my own bake sale purchase. Other than my pies, there were only two others on the table at the time, and I knew this was my chance to finally have a pie that I did not have to bake myself. And I knew right away which one it would be:

Peanut butter pie.

(That was not the part that may lead to your disappointment.)

I had neither made nor eaten a peanut butter pie until now, and I have no idea what I was waiting for. Wow! Talk about a rich, sweet pie. It was so good, and so worth it’s $6 price tag. I could pay near that for just one slice in most restaurants!

(Here’s where the disappointment comes in.)

With all the sugar that walked out of that bake sale, into my house, and directly into all of our veins, I knew there was no way I could make the pie I had originally planned to make this weekend and still live to tell you about it while in a sugar-induced coma. So, I didn’t.

I’m sorry. But I promise that you will not be anywhere close to disappointed with the festive pie I make for next Sunday. All I have to say about it is…peppermintOreoshot fudge. You won’t want to miss it! (And I promise I will not be shopping any bake sales this week.)

Until then, I’ll share this picture with you of the pie my family enjoyed, thanks to the generous, anonymous person who brought it to the bake sale. And thanks to you for your patience!

Yours in pie,

Mindy

I can’t share the recipe for this pie since I have no idea who made it. But I would love to get some recipes for Peanut Butter Pie. My taste buds detected chunky peanut butter and cream cheese in this pie, but whatever your recipe, please share! You can post a recipe in the comment section below, or email it to me at pieonsunday@gmail.com

 

Pie Fair Lady


Pie Fair Lady recently featured my post about Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie. If you’re not familiar, the blog is a round-up of “the best sweet, savory, big [and] small pies food bloggers have to offer”. Each post shares a photo along with a description of each pie and a link back to the original blog post.

Pie Fair Lady is written by Rachel Rappaport, a food writer, recipe developer, and author of cookbooks, including The Everything Whole Foods Cookbook and The Everything Healthy Slow Cooker Cookbook. Rachel also shares her original recipes on her food blog, Coconut & Lime, which offers over 1200 recipes for good, wholesome food.

If you get a chance, check out Pie on Sunday’s appearance at Pie Fair Lady, along with the many other pie recipes featured. And if you’re looking for some good wholesome recipes of other kinds, check out Rachel’s Coconut & Lime blog. You’ll be glad you did.

Yours in pie,

Mindy

 

11.26.2012

Toasted Pecan Pie from Hometown Cooking


Even though we just celebrated Thanksgiving, and I have plenty for which to be thankful, this will be a short post this week.

Why?

I’m getting ready for Christmas.

Again.

Every year it arrives so quickly, and every year I’m not ready in time, even after swearing that I will start earlier the next year. (And I imagine that I’m not alone.)

But it never happens…except for this year.

I want to spend time with my family in the days leading up to Christmas...baking cookies, making candy, eating pie (wait till you see what I have planned for this next Sunday!), sledding, drinking hot cocoa, (or dreaming of sledding while drinking hot cocoa, since we probably won’t have any snow by then), shoveling snow, building snow forts, (again, just dreaming), reading Christmas stories, watching Christmas movies, helping my kids make their Christmas presents…all the fun stuff that makes the season bright.

What I will not be doing this year is what I do every year...staying up until 2 a.m. on Christmas Eve wrapping presents because I waited until the last minute. (Literally. I’m still wrapping presents after Santa lays a finger aside his nose, gives a wink – or is it a nod? – and up the chimney he rises.)
 
I have a good start. I spent much of this weekend shopping and running errands, so I’m ahead of the game, and I want to keep it that way.

So, I’m sharing the recipe for the Toasted Pecan Pie that I made for Thanksgiving. (My mom also made a delicious traditional pumpkin pie. I’ll have to share the recipe with you sometime.)

For now, I’m off to do more shopping and prepping for Christmas. Only 29 days left!

Hoping you had a happy Thanksgiving!

Yours in pie,

Mindy

My 4-year-old daughter couldn't wait to eat this pie and started with the crust.
 
This is my favorite pecan pie. Well, just barely, after diving into the Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie I made last week to celebrate my son’s birthday. This pie is so yummy! I entered it in the Iowa State Fair in 2004 and took first place in the pecan pie class. Toasting the pecans brings out their flavor and gives them a nice crunch, and the added buttery, maple pecan topping really puts this pie over the top!

I found this recipe more than ten years ago, in the August 2001 issue of Hometown Cooking Magazine, and it’s been my favorite pecan pie ever since. Hometown Cooking is also my favorite cooking magazine. Or I should say, was. It’s no longer published. It ran from October 1999 until its last issue in August 2002. I know because I have every issue. (Yes, still. And they are not going anywhere.) Each issue featured the best hometown cooks from across the country and their favorite recipes, and highlighted the community cookbooks which featured those recipes. The magazine was such a great source of delicious tried-and-true dishes, which were also tested in the kitchens at Better Homes & Gardens. (Meredith Corporation published both magazines.)
 
 
 

So while you make and enjoy this tried-and-true Toasted Pecan Pie, I’ll be scanning recipes and catching up on old issues of Hometown Cooking – after I finish my Christmas shopping!
 


Toasted Pecan Pie
from Hometown Cooking Magazine, August 2001

Pastry for single-crust 9-inch pie

4 slightly beaten eggs

1 c. sugar

2/3 c. light corn syrup

1/3 c. pure maple syrup

¼ c. butter, melted

1 tsp. vanilla

1/8 tsp. salt

¾ c. pecan halves, toasted and chopped

¾ c. pecan halves, toasted

3 T. sugar

3 T. pure maple syrup

1 T. butter

 
For filling:
Combine eggs, 1 c. sugar, corn syrup, 1/3 c. maple syrup, ¼ c. melted butter, vanilla, and salt. Mix well. Stir in ¾ c. chopped pecans. Pour filling into prepared pastry shell. Cover edge of pie with foil to prevent overbrowning. Bake pie in 350° oven for 45-50 minutes, until knife inserted off-center comes out clean.
 

For topping:
Combine ¾ c. pecan halves, 3 T. sugar, 3 T. maple syrup, and 1 T. butter in microwave-safe bowl. Microwave on 100% power (high) for 1 ½ minutes; stir. Spoon the topping over the warm, baked pie. Cool completely on wire rack.
 

To toast pecans:
Spread pecan halves in a single layer in a shallow baking pan. Bake in 350° oven for 5-10 minutes or until light golden brown, watching carefully and stirring once or twice to prevent burning.
 

Special note: The magazine gives nutrition information for each recipe. This recipe was divided into 12 servings, and I don’t think I’ve ever cut a pie into that many slices! Even so, I’m not going to freak you out with the fact that this pie has 453 calories per serving (that’s 1/12th of the pie)…just enjoy it before you set your New Year’s resolutions.

 

11.19.2012

Turning 7, and Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie



I think I may have experienced my worst nightmare.
(Probably not really, but it feels like it at the moment.)
My son, my first-born, my Buggy-love, turned 7 over the weekend.
7.
Seven.



I know. It doesn’t sound like that big of a deal. It’s not like he turned one….or five….or sixteen. It’s not one of the big birthdays. But yet, it is.



It’s monumental. Because he’s not one anymore, when he was still my baby. He’s not five anymore, ready to start kindergarten. (And thank God, he’s not sixteen. I know we have a few years to go, but I already predict that he should not…I repeat…not be given keys to a car. Perhaps ever. Because he is, without a doubt, his father’s son.)
It’s monumental because he’s changed.


He’s taller, for one…..smarter…..even more handsome. And he’s lived a little more life, which means he wants more independence. So, he’s testing the waters…..a lot more than he used to. (A lot more than I’m used to.)


But to deal with it, while not ignoring it, I’m choosing to focus on the positive changes that come with his age. For instance, when he’s not pushing her around, he steps in as the protective big brother to his little sister. (Though she’s quite capable of sticking up for herself, thank you very much.)


He also expresses a greater compassion for others, especially for those who have less than he does. For his birthday party, he asked his friends to not bring him gifts, but instead to bring new, unwrapped toys that he can collect and donate to our local Toys for Tots for this Christmas gift-giving season.
And, he continues to make us laugh in new, unexpected ways. As a family, we rounded out his birthday by going out for pizza. He sat next to his dad on the inside of the booth, and when he was ready to head to the restroom to clean up, he proceeded to slide under the table to get out. My husband quickly stopped him, and this is how the conversation went:
My husband: “Whoa. What are you doing?”
My son: “Going to the bathroom.”
My husband: “You’re seven now. Are you going to be a little boy or a big boy?”
My son: “A big boy, so I’m going to go wash my hands and face.”
My husband: “How do you think a big boy would get out of the booth?”
My son: “Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. I know. I’ll climb over the back.”
Nightmare’s over.
Yep. With table manners like those, I don’t think he’ll be leaving us for a looooong time.
(And that’s alright with me!)
Yours in pie,
Mindy
My son loves pie. Loves it. So he’s really enjoying the fact that he gets to have pie every week, now that I’m making pie a lot more often. I really haven’t been too adventurous, I’m kind of a pie purist and just like more traditional pies. I had not yet tried adding chocolate to pecan pie, and when I came across this recipe from Laurie at cookin’ up north, I knew it was time to start. Laurie says this is “hands down [her] favorite pie ever”, and I thought the chocolate chips would make having pie a little more special for my son on his birthday. This pie is definitely deliciously rich, like eating a chocolate chip cookie with, um...pecan pie. (Does that mean it has twice the calories, or half the calories of each?)
As listed below, Laurie’s recipe calls for filling an unbaked crust, so of course, thinking the bottom may not get golden and flaky, I first partially pre-baked the crust, then filled it. I wish I had just baked it once, as Laurie did. While the crust tasted fine, had a nice texture and was done on the bottom, partially pre-baking it created some avenues for seepage of the filling, which also allowed some of the filling to spill over the edge of the pie plate from underneath the crust…and all over the bottom of my oven. Next time I will save a step and just fill an unbaked crust…as the recipe calls for!
Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie
3 eggs
1 c. light corn syrup
½ c. sugar
¼ c. melted butter
1 tsp. vanilla extract
1 c. pecan halves
¾ c. chocolate chips

Combine eggs, corn syrup, sugar, melted butter, and vanilla in bowl. Stir in pecans and chocolate chips. Pour filling into pastry-lined pie plate. Bake at 350° for 50-55 minutes until done. Cool completely on wire rack.




I shared this recipe on:


Check out all the great recipes at this Linky Party!

11.12.2012

Bringing Flaky Back


Before I tell you how I brought flaky back, don't forget to check back next week for the Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie I will be making to celebrate my son’s birthday. I don’t have a recipe to share with you this week because I didn’t make a pie this week.

Instead, I spent the weekend with my sister in Rochester, Minnesota, at the North Central Hearts at Home Conference. Hearts at Home is a Christian-oriented resource for moms whose mission, according to their website, is to “encourage, educate, and equip every mom in every season of motherhood using Christian values to strengthen families.” The conference was beyond uplifting and inspiring, with keynotes from Dr. Juli Slattery, formerly of Focus on the Family, and my personal favorites, Jim Bob and Michelle Duggar. (You might remember me sharing with you that my dad could feed their whole family with his massive vegetable garden.) They certainly fulfilled their mission.

Last night after putting the kids to bed, because I was not home to cook all weekend, my husband and I shared some Chinese take-out for a late dinner. After devouring the lo mein, egg rolls, and crab rangoon, I cracked open my fortune cookie: “I am always doing that which I cannot do in order that I may learn how to do it.”
 
 

Huh. Whaddya know.

I thought it was interesting timing, considering the weekend I spent learning more about my job as a mom. Not that I don’t know how to be a mom already. But I always want to improve and learn anything I can that will help me do it better.

As a teacher, I approached my job in the same way. I was in a constant search for a better way to help my individual students learn in their individual ways, and the best way to figure that out was simply by doing it.

I’m a firm believer that the search for meaning is innate. We are born with a desire to make sense of life and everything in it. It’s what drives us deep within, whether we do that by making connections, asking questions, inferring, etc. Whatever our strategy, whatever the context, our ultimate goal is to make sense of the situation. And one powerful tool for doing so is analogy.

Analogy is the vehicle that gets us from what we already know to what we need to know. It’s a tool I used multiple times in each lesson as a reading teacher. And I’ve found it can be used effectively in pie baking as well.

I’m not sure you’ve noticed in the photos, but for a while, my pie crusts were not very flaky. They were lacking the quality I’m accustomed to producing, and I didn’t understand why. So I began to investigate. I didn’t do it simply by researching methods other pie bakers were successfully using. I did it by changing and testing my own methods.

What I first realized was that the quality of my crusts began changing shortly after I switched from using store-bought commercial lard to locally-produced lard, the kind without all the preservatives and hydrogenation. But I knew it couldn’t be the lard itself that was causing the lack of flakiness. So I began adjusting one step at a time, from the amount of water I was using, to how much mixing of the dough I was doing, to the time the dough spent chilling. Then I thought about the amount of lard I was using.

When using store-bought lard, which comes in one-pound blocks, rather than measuring by volume in a measuring cup, I would just use half the block, or eight ounces, which I figured was about one cup, the amount I use for making my pie crust recipe. When I switched to using locally-produced lard, which comes in a large tub, I had to measure the lard by scooping it into a measuring cup.

Here’s where the analogy comes in.

Several years ago, I drove four hours north to take a bread-baking class at a popular kitchen shop in Minneapolis. (Back then, I had not yet learned about the value of time, or of gas.) I don’t really spend much time baking bread these days. I tend to let my bread machine do most of the work for me, so I can spend my time baking pies. (Maybe someday someone will invent a pie-baking machine.) Even so, I did get something valuable out of the class, which recently came in very handy while I was working to regain the quality of my pie crusts.

What if I measured the lard by weight, rather than by volume?

In the bread-baking class, I learned that the flour should always be measured by weighing it, to ensure that the same amount of flour was used every time, for consistent results. I realized when measuring the locally-produced lard that I probably was getting some variation each time since what actually made it into the measuring cup could vary. Perhaps my pie crust no longer had enough fat to make it flaky because I wasn’t measuring the amount I was previously using.

So I started weighing my lard with a kitchen scale, instead of using a measuring cup. And it worked.
 
 

It all made sense, and I brought flaky back.

The moral of the story? The next time you want to learn something new or improve what you are already doing, just consider what you are already doing, do it differently, and do that which you cannot do.

Make sense of that.

Yours in pie,

Mindy

 

11.06.2012

Send Me Your Favorite Pie Recipes!


Yesterday I received an invitation in my inbox from Farm Flavor to join their group board on Pinterest, “Favorite Holiday Recipes”, and pin some pie recipes from my blog. If you’re not familiar with Farm Flavor, they feature recipes in their magazines and on their websites, with a goal of educating readers by connecting food and farm. Their publications include Tennessee Home & Farm, My Indiana Home, and Illinois Partners.

That got me thinking about sharing pie recipes -- specifically, you sharing your recipes with me. And with the other person who reads my blog. (Thanks, Mom.)

So, I want your favorite pie recipes. They don’t have to be for the holidays, or for Sunday. Any day of the week or time of year will do. And they don't have to be only dessert pies. Savory pies are certainly warranted, and I'll take any recipe with "pie" in the name. (Unless it's for a mud pie that actually contains mud. I'll leave that pie-making to my kids.) Be sure to include the type of crust used or a recipe for it.

It doesn’t matter how you got the recipes, whether you developed them yourself, received them from a friend, found them in a cookbook or online, or used a very old-fashioned method -- clipping them from the pages of a magazine or newspaper. Just give credit to the source if you can, and if you made any changes to the recipe, as Evelyn Birkby says, I want the changes. Give me the recipe the way you make it.

I will try to make some of the pies eventually and feature them here on Pie on Sunday. To get your recipes to me, you have two options:

·        Post the recipe(s) in a comment at the bottom of this post. (Please post a new comment for each recipe.)


·        Email the recipe(s) to me at: pieonsunday@gmail.com.

 
I can’t wait to get your recipes! And if you get a chance, stop in at Farm Flavor’s website (they have a ton of great recipes, among other things) or check out all the recipe pins from various food bloggers on their “Favorite Holiday Recipes” board on Pinterest.

Yours in pie,

Mindy